CO129-466 - Individuals - 1920 — Page 657

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

##

Upon reflection, no honest man likes to speak ill of a confrere needlessly, especially when he has received much kindness from, and been on terms of friendship with such a person for many years. But such private amicable feelings should certainly receive consideration only after, and not before, the good of the public service. I am aware that this view may not be the accepted one, officially, at the moment, and that any disparagement of the intended successor will probably be construed into a disparagement of myself; but this risk I must accept, in the interests of the Colony and of the Department in which I have served for over 20 years as its official head.

###

It is my carefully considered opinion, formed after 13 years' knowledge of Commander Beckwith, that it would not be to the public interest to appoint him to the post of Harbour Master of Hongkong, for the following reasons:

It goes without saying that an official should inspire respect with those above him as well as those beneath him in office. During the 13 years of Commander Beckwith's service under me, he has given me little cause to trust his judgement or his loyalty. He is heartily disliked by most of those below him in the Harbour Department, and I have...

Edit History

2026-06-26 15:00:22 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
## Upon reflection, no honest man likes to speak ill of a confrere needlessly, especially when he has received much kindness from, and been on terms of friendship with such a person for many years. But such private amicable feelings should certainly receive consideration only after, and not before, the good of the public service. I am aware that this view may not be the accepted one, officially, at the moment, and that any disparagement of the intended successor will probably be construed into a disparagement of myself; but this risk I must accept, in the interests of the Colony and of the Department in which I have served for over 20 years as its official head. ### It is my carefully considered opinion, formed after 13 years' knowledge of Commander Beckwith, that it would not be to the public interest to appoint him to the post of Harbour Master of Hongkong, for the following reasons: It goes without saying that an official should inspire respect with those above him as well as those beneath him in office. During the 13 years of Commander Beckwith's service under me, he has given me little cause to trust his judgement or his loyalty. He is heartily disliked by most of those below him in the Harbour Department, and I have...
Baseline (Original)
soa. 1 cutory r O 11803' US070 । IATARITZO E 653 Jambrapal tuodtak SV **2 TASO* boasag mad dride 9909brogantius ad) quino19191 *[ tad) oriondo I usevičsı grostuquas gu lo taajjes 90t 4 We 24 1088999UR (E født batsang 101 esdut ¿ĺtasınpja mi tì • ►. A 2 di£ysd f 1 nobrasno) od 11in zotond voodial to beog za azoitabasamu991 en rok bolna wood tod svað 1 ma (Jasastikan ga gå kontot ad of (essay sdh to grillit sdi ni 990alia ga sa kun (saltsang sål nood ofisdlıd and -9208114 Ridt diiy tasanes alat brustason að þégie 1stdan qokalqo zu 1910 of (ikustomis: teod Iroqud sit arad I „t Fastingsd sdł, ni sianos çam b10991 a Jadi tebro ai dgaonan Jastanut nidh no amsiy ɖ to asyidata Inimolo) sdf ui bas andi »d) 10 (94silab sd) la numisanoɔ titui studi Født 1991 ausisdinov9a 1 (aniža)robus xa i dant Lukətungan (lub sid) 29mojui sautui sit ni hau mun tuonsak sildng adt 1 s{datavas upon ne. No honest map likes to reflect on or speak ill of • confrere meadlessly, especially when he has received much kindness from, and been on terms of friendship with such a person for many years, But such private anicable feelings should certainly receive consideration only after, and not before, the good of the public service. 1 an aware that this vies say not be the accepted one, officially, at the moment, and that any disparagement of the intended successo will probably be only construed into a disparagement of Byself; but this risk I rust accept, in the interests of the folony and of the Department in which I have served for over 20 years 19 as its official head. 3. - It is my carefully considered opinion, formed after 13 years knowledge of Commander Neckwith, that it would not be to the public interest to appoint him to the post of Harbour Kaster of Hongkong, for the following rea- BOAB: It goes without saying that an official should inspire with respect those above him as well as those beneath bi in office. Dubing the 13 years of Commander Beckwith's service under me, he has given me little cause to trust his judgement or his loyalty. He is heartily disliked by most of those below him in the Barbour Department, and I have (14791592 (atao been
2026-06-26 15:00:22 · Baseline
View content

soa.

1 cutory r

O

11803'

US070 ।

IATARITZO E

653

Jambrapal tuodtak

SV **2 TASO*

boasag mad dride 9909brogantius ad) quino19191 *[

tad) oriondo I usevičsı grostuquas gu lo taajjes 90t

4

We

24

1088999UR (E født batsang 101 esdut ¿ĺtasınpja mi tì

►.

A 2 di£ysd f 1 nobrasno) od 11in zotond voodial to beog

za azoitabasamu991 en rok bolna wood tod svað 1 ma

(Jasastikan ga gå kontot ad of (essay sdh to grillit

sdi ni 990alia ga sa kun (saltsang sål nood ofisdlıd and

-9208114 Ridt diiy tasanes alat brustason að þégie 1stdan

qokalqo zu 1910 of (ikustomis: teod Iroqud sit arad I „t

Fastingsd sdł, ni sianos çam b10991 a Jadi tebro ai

dgaonan

Jastanut nidh no amsiy ɖ to asyidata Inimolo) sdf ui bas

andi

»d) 10 (94silab sd) la numisanoɔ titui studi

Født 1991 ausisdinov9a 1 (aniža)robus xa i dant Lukətungan (lub sid) 29mojui sautui sit ni hau mun tuonsak sildng adt

1

s{datavas

upon ne. No honest map likes to reflect on or speak ill of

• confrere meadlessly, especially when he has received much

kindness from, and been on terms of friendship with such a

person for many years, But such private anicable feelings

should certainly receive consideration only after, and not

before, the good of the public service. 1 an aware that

this vies say not be the accepted one, officially, at the

moment, and that any disparagement of the intended successo

will probably be only construed into a disparagement of

Byself; but this risk I rust accept, in the interests of

the folony and of the Department in which I have served for

over 20 years 19 as its official head.

3.

-

It is my carefully considered opinion, formed

after 13 years knowledge of Commander Neckwith, that it

would not be to the public interest to appoint him to the

post of Harbour Kaster of Hongkong, for the following rea-

BOAB:

It goes without saying that an official should

inspire with respect those above him as well as those beneath

bi in office. Dubing the 13 years of Commander Beckwith's

service under me, he has given me little cause to trust his judgement or his loyalty. He is heartily disliked by most

of those below him in the Barbour Department, and I have

(14791592 (atao

been

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.